SF&F lately has been strangely obsessed with themes of mass murder for the "Greater Good", as well as other forms of extreme moral compromise for various lofty(ish) goals. My latest fannish love, the show I kind of refuse to call 12 Monkeys (it's called Splinter, I tell you, Splinter!) is part of that strange glut of texts dealing with extreme - and sometimes really rather artificial - ethical dilemmas of that sort. It's not the first such text that I've been obsessed with in recent years, though. Two of the previous ones caused me to produce long, unfinished essays, which I recently decided to post to tumblr (though there is no discernible fan presence for either of the two book series in question there).
I'm somewhat troubled by my own fascination. Unfortunately I ran into messy clumps of thought tangle before I could really get to the bottom of that, or get to any sort of definitive point, with either of these two unfinished beasts. (My brain is really only half-smart, and in situations like this, it shows.)
Still, I poured a lot of work into these, and maybe someone will find them a little bit interesting even in this fragmentary shape. Or maybe not, that's also fine. I'm just putting them here because, well, they already exist, so why not.
Links to the relevant tumblr posts:On Morally Evaluating the Mass Murderers of Terra Ignota (This is probably the more useless of the two; though it does, at least, have some bullet points of the things I still meant to cover, i.e. "where it actually would have gotten interesting, probably".)
Dirty Laundry, part 1;
part 2 (This works fairly well as is, but is lacking a crucial third chapter on the problems of trying to have your Lovecraftian apocalypse and subvert it, too.)
Also kind of relevant:
My review of The Delirium BriefAll this is very much the background for most of my ongoing, disorganised and meandering "Splinter" discussion on tumblr, as well as all of my fic writing of the last two or three years.
ETA:
1.) This is actually a slightly weird & arguably off framing for "Splinter", although my discussion of the show *does* grow from all this because that's where my mind has been.
2.) I should just go and read some actual philosophy already, instead of fumbling around in the dark for years...